Q Before completing this assignment, be sure to learn about Antigone and her dilemma, and also understand how dilemmas in general can often be framed as a contrast between nomos and physis. Prompts First, in your own words, explain the distinction between nomos and physis, and how it relates to Antigone's dilemma of burying or not burying her brother. What's going on in Thebes such that this choice has become a dilemma for her? Second, what is any dilemma that you have faced in life where the choice of action is unclear, and one course of action might be based on nomos, and the other on physis? Be sure to explain *how* the one choice is nomos, and the other is physis, and be sure that it's clear you understand the distinction between the two. Notes on substance and style • As always in this class, be sure to write more than one paragraph. There are two prompts here, so it's a good idea to write at least two paragraphs • Write enough to explore the questions. Think of ideas as you write, and then explore them. Write at least several sentences for each prompt. • There is no single "right answer" here in explaining your situation, but there are answers that show more thought than others. Be sure to make specific connections • Be sure your answer contains echoes of the materials in Canvas, especially in the first prompt, about Antigone. • Be sure your personal dilemma contains specific reference to which side is nomos, and which is physis. • Of course, avoid TMI or "too much information" — it's always okay to be discreet when writing things on the internet, even for your college class. Rubric Journal Writing (JW) Journal Writing (JW) Criteria Ratings Pts This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeFoundation Does this submission have info related to the materials provided in Canvas, and does it use the Canvas materials as the basis of well-founded responses? Is the assignment complete? 10 to >5.0 pts Full Marks Shows mastery of a wide range of facts from the Canvas material; facts are deployed well to support the argument. Assignment is complete. 5 to >0.0 pts Partial Marks Some facts are drawn from the materials, but there is room for even more; facts may need to be more clearly tied to the argument. Assignment may not be complete. 0 pts No Marks Little or no evidence of drawing on the materials in Canvas to support the argument. Assignment may not be at all complete. 10 pts This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeClarity Is it easy to make sense of the ideas written here, or are they obscure? This criterion includes both the mechanics of writing, and the general ease of understanding the big point of the writing. 5 to >3.0 pts Full Marks Clearly and coherently expresses an idea. It rings true. It hits the nail on the head. Shows mastery of the conventions of written English. 3 to >0.0 pts Partial Marks Does a generally ok job of getting the point across. In some places, could use a bit if editing to be clearer. May need some work to adhere closer to the conventions of written English. 0 pts No Marks Very obscure. Hard for a reader to understand the argument. Perhaps does not address the prompt adequately or at all. May not adhere at all to the conventions of written English. 5 pts This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeImagination Does this writing show real independence of mind, going beyond the basic facts to make a point that is plausible and compelling? 5 to >3.0 pts Full Marks Goes above and beyond in relating the materials to the world today, or to personal life, or to the educational process (as relevant to the prompt). A real spark of insight. 3 to >0.0 pts Partial Marks Makes a generally good connection with the world today, or personal life, or the educational process (as relevant to the prompt). Basically makes a solid point. 0 pts No Marks Shows little or no imaginative connection between the Canvas materials and the world today. Little or no spark of insight. May be just hard to understand. 5 pts Total Points: 20 PreviousNext